Ken,
I agree that we are builders -- the building part doesn't scare me, it gets me excited about the possibilities. I do think members will willingly jump in to create something of permanence for the Guild.
I still think location is the big issue. I am sometimes envious of you guys in the UK with regards to everyone's proximity. England is smaller than my home state of Georgia. Add in Scotland and your about the size of Kansas. For us, location is important because a permanent headquarters would have to be fairly and centrally and wisely located with regards to the membership. I am reconciled to driving 10 hours or more (ore usually flying) to Guild events. Most others are not able or willing to go to that expense. I know that if the Guild Hall were 2 hours from me I would be there a whole lot more than if it were 14 hours from me. So I do see location as an issue.
Of course, someone could donate a suitable piece of property to the Guild and do away with the issue...
Building multiple regional campuses is an interesting idea, but the costs associated with buying land and building a Guild Hall would be difficult to handle when multiplied by multiple sites. Perhaps long-term that is an idea to entertain.
I don't think building with the idea of relocating is feasible, either. We can't just move the Guild every few years.
I think the benefits of a permanent headquarters would be tremendous.
I'm out of time for now...