Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#8442 - 06/10/03 02:24 AM New Slick
scott baney Offline
Member

Registered: 06/07/03
Posts: 2
Loc: Eureka, Montana
I recently bought a L&I J White 2 3/4" slick. Its been sharpened with a very slight radius to the cutting edge. I was wondering if this is right or if it should be sharpened square? What bevel should it be sharpened at? Also, as I have lapped the back of it there is still about a quarter to three eights stip down both sides that aren't square. Do I just keep working on it until its perfectly flat? Thanks for any advice.

Scott

Top
#8443 - 06/11/03 01:00 AM Re: New Slick
Roger Nair Offline
Member

Registered: 10/20/99
Posts: 463
Loc: Bakerton, WV, USA
White chisels are of the best quality, congratulations on your purchase. I have also wondered about the radius one often finds on old edge tools. In theory, I believe the radius will give a slight skew to the edge and aid the user with less effort pushing the slick, also if the back rolls up at the edge, the edge comes out of the cut and is somewhat less prone to digging in. On the other hand, a blunt edge flat back slick will sever grain better with the back right to the surface and a blunt edge will chop to the bottom and corners easier. So, if you are looking to work joints go blunt and for shaping freehand I think the radius is fine.

The reason the radius is there, may not have anything to do with the above. The sides of a chisel tend to wear more at the edge than the center, by my observation. So hand sharpeners wanted an edge first and not a perfect square edge, so over time a radius developed.

Old references, such as Audel's, recommend 15 degrees on a paring chisel and 25 degrees on a framing chisel.

Top

Moderator:  Jim Rogers, mdfinc 
Newest Members
Janne_Sweden, Whiskey_I, justified, Frank_S, cwhitepoplar
4929 Registered Users