This isn't about personal preference. Barr chisels are very well made, without question, however they are made in a different style than the traditional American framing chisels. My argument is that if one wants a particular type of tool, then buy that type, don't injure an antique tool, which is no longer available. If Barr made a chisel in the style of an old Witherby, Globe, Pexto etc., then I would buy a couple.